Independent medicine information from a GPhC-registered UK pharmacy · Checked against NHS, MHRA and NICE sources

Medicine information

Zopiclone or zolpidem? How they compare with diazepam, temazepam and melatonin

Zopiclone or zolpidem? Both are UK-licensed only for short-term insomnia, and NICE found no compelling evidence that one is better. This guide compares them with eszopiclone, diazepam, temazepam and melatonin: licences, half-life, driving and legal status.

Last updated 16 November 2026

Written by the Your Meds UK editorial team · Sources: NHS, MHRA, NICE, EMC

Illustration of a balance scale holding a sleep mask and lavender on a bedside table at dusk

Zopiclone or zolpidem? In the UK, both are Z-drug sleeping tablets licensed only for short-term insomnia in adults, and NICE found no compelling evidence that one works better than the other. The main differences are how long each stays in your body and how long you should wait before driving. Your prescriber chooses which one suits you.

Key facts

  • What they are: Zopiclone, zolpidem and eszopiclone are Z-drugs. Diazepam and temazepam are benzodiazepines. Melatonin is a different type of sleep medicine.
  • Licensed use (UK): Short-term insomnia in adults for the Z-drugs and temazepam. Diazepam only when insomnia comes with anxiety. Melatonin (Circadin) for adults aged 55 or over.
  • Legal status: Zopiclone, zolpidem, diazepam and temazepam are Class C controlled drugs. Melatonin is prescription-only. Eszopiclone is listed as prescription-only; ask a pharmacist about controlled-drug rules.
  • Needs a prescription: Yes, all of them.
  • Last checked: November 2026

People often search for which sleeping tablet is “better”. This guide compares zopiclone with zolpidem, eszopiclone, diazepam, temazepam and melatonin using the official UK product information, NICE and UK law. It does not rank them, because the right choice depends on you. For the full picture of zopiclone itself, read our complete guide to zopiclone.

At a glance: how the main sleep medicines compare

Medicine Type UK licensed use (summary) Half-life in the SmPC UK legal status
Zopiclone Z-drug Short-term insomnia in adults About 5 hours Class C, Schedule 4 Part I
Zolpidem Z-drug Short-term insomnia in adults that is debilitating or causing severe distress Mean 2.4 hours Class C, Schedule 4 Part I
Eszopiclone (Lunivia) Z-drug Insomnia in adults, usually short term See the SmPC Prescription-only (ask about controlled-drug rules)
Diazepam Benzodiazepine Short-term relief of severe anxiety, including anxiety with insomnia See the SmPC Class C, Schedule 4 Part I
Temazepam Benzodiazepine Short-term treatment of severe or disabling sleep problems 5.3 to 11.5 hours (young volunteers) Class C, Schedule 3
Melatonin (Circadin) Melatonin receptor medicine Short-term primary insomnia in people aged 55 or over 3.5 to 4 hours Prescription-only medicine

Half-life is the time it takes for the level in your blood to halve. A longer half-life can mean more chance of feeling drowsy the next morning. It does not tell you which medicine works better.

Zopiclone vs zolpidem: what is actually different

On paper, the two medicines are very alike. The zopiclone SmPC licenses it for “the short-term treatment of insomnia in adults”. The zolpidem SmPC uses similar wording but adds that the insomnia should be debilitating or causing severe distress.

Both SmPCs say treatment should be as short as possible. It should not go beyond four weeks, including the time taken to reduce the dose and stop. The real differences are smaller:

  • How long it stays in your body. Zopiclone’s elimination half-life is about 5 hours. Zolpidem’s is shorter, with a mean of 2.4 hours.
  • Driving the next day. The NHS says not to drive, ride a bike or use machinery for 12 hours after zopiclone. For zolpidem, the NHS advice is 8 hours.

Both can cause dependence, and the NHS says it is possible to become addicted to either one. Neither is “the safe one”. For the full list of zopiclone’s effects, see our guide to side effects of zopiclone. If you want to know how quickly zopiclone starts working, read how long zopiclone takes to work.

What NICE says about choosing between them

NICE looked at this exact question in its technology appraisal TA77 on zaleplon, zolpidem and zopiclone. Its recommendations are clear:

  • Sleeping tablets should only be considered after non-drug measures have been properly considered.
  • They should be prescribed for short periods only, in strict line with their licence.
  • Because of the “lack of compelling evidence to distinguish between zolpidem, zopiclone or the shorter-acting benzodiazepine hypnotics”, the one with the lowest purchase cost should be used.
  • Switching from one to another should only happen if you have side effects thought to be caused by that specific medicine.
  • If one of these medicines has not worked for you, you should not be prescribed any of the others.

So in the NHS, the choice is rarely about one being “stronger”. It is about your health, your other medicines and cost. If zopiclone has stopped working, swapping to zolpidem is not the usual answer. Speak to your prescriber instead.

Eszopiclone vs zopiclone

Eszopiclone is closely related to zopiclone. It is in the same Z-drug group of the international ATC classification. In the US it is sold as Lunesta. Some older articles say it is not available in the UK, but that is out of date.

A UK product, Lunivia (eszopiclone), now has a UK licence and appears on the electronic medicines compendium. Its SmPC licenses it for insomnia in adults, “usually for short-term duration”. It says treatment is typically no more than four weeks including tapering, although it allows a longer period in some cases.

The Lunivia patient leaflet says not to drive or do hazardous activities for 12 hours after taking it. It also says you should have 8 hours to devote to sleep. Its UK SmPC and leaflet list it as a prescription-only medicine. Eszopiclone is not named separately in the UK controlled drug lists, so ask your pharmacist how the rules apply to your prescription.

Diazepam or zopiclone?

Diazepam is a benzodiazepine, not a sleeping tablet in the usual sense. The NHS describes diazepam as a medicine for anxiety, seizures and muscle spasms.

The diazepam SmPC covers sleep only as part of anxiety. It is licensed for short-term relief of severe anxiety, “occurring alone or in association with insomnia”. It is not licensed for insomnia on its own.

The NHS says diazepam should only be used short term, up to 4 weeks, because longer use can cause addiction and withdrawal symptoms. Zopiclone and diazepam both make you drowsy, so they should never be combined unless a prescriber has decided it is right. Our zopiclone interactions guide explains why.

Temazepam vs zopiclone

Temazepam is a benzodiazepine sleeping tablet. Its UK SmPC licenses it for short-term treatment of sleep problems that are severe or disabling, or causing extreme distress. It should not be continued beyond 4 weeks, including tapering.

NICE’s appraisal also covered the shorter-acting benzodiazepine sleeping tablets. It found no compelling evidence to tell them apart from zolpidem and zopiclone. The biggest practical difference is legal. Temazepam is in Schedule 3 of the Misuse of Drugs Regulations, which carries more legal requirements than Schedule 4 Part I.

Zopiclone vs melatonin

Melatonin is a different kind of medicine from zopiclone. In the UK, it has a much narrower licence.

  • Adults aged 55 or over. Circadin prolonged-release tablets are licensed for short-term primary insomnia with poor-quality sleep in people aged 55 or over. The SmPC says treatment may continue for up to thirteen weeks.
  • Children. Slenyto is licensed for insomnia in some children and teenagers with ADHD or autism, when sleep routines have not helped enough.
  • Under 55s. The NHS says adults under 55 can take melatonin only if a specialist recommends it.

Melatonin is available on prescription only in the UK. It is not “a milder zopiclone”, and it is not a substitute you can swap in yourself.

Every drug in the comparison needs a prescription, but the law treats them differently. Zopiclone, zolpidem, diazepam and temazepam all appear in the Class C list of the Misuse of Drugs Act 1971.

Medicine Class Schedule (Misuse of Drugs Regulations 2001)
Zopiclone C Schedule 4 Part I
Zolpidem C Schedule 4 Part I
Diazepam C Schedule 4 Part I
Temazepam C Schedule 3
Melatonin, eszopiclone Not named in these lists; both are prescription-only medicines (ask your pharmacist about eszopiclone)

You can check the schedules yourself in Schedule 4 and Schedule 3 of the 2001 Regulations. For what this means for your prescription, see is zopiclone a controlled drug? and our guide to controlled drugs in the UK.

The safety rules that apply to all of them

Whichever medicine you are prescribed, the same basic rules apply. Take it exactly as your prescriber tells you.

  • Short courses only. The NHS insomnia page says sleeping pills are only prescribed for a few days, or weeks at most, if insomnia is very bad and other treatments have not worked.
  • Be careful with alcohol. Avoid it with zopiclone, and follow the advice in your own medicine’s leaflet.
  • Never mix sleeping tablets or add over-the-counter sleep aids without asking a pharmacist.
  • Do not stop suddenly after regular use. Your prescriber can plan how to stop. Read our guides to zopiclone withdrawal and whether zopiclone is addictive.
  • Never share your tablets. They are prescribed for you alone.

Which one is right for you is a clinical decision

No sleeping tablet treats the cause of insomnia. The NHS says insomnia usually gets better by changing your sleeping habits, and you may be offered cognitive behavioural therapy (CBT). Our insomnia guide covers these steps.

If a medicine is needed, your prescriber will think about your age, other conditions, other medicines, alcohol use, driving and any past dependence. Do not switch, combine or change the dose yourself. Check the right amount in our zopiclone dose guide and ask your pharmacist if you are unsure.

When to get help

Call 999 or go to A&E if someone has taken more than prescribed and is very drowsy, hard to wake or breathing slowly, especially with alcohol, opioids or other sedatives. Also call 999 for a severe allergic reaction, such as a swollen face or throat or trouble breathing.

Call NHS 111 or speak to your GP if you are very drowsy the next day, you do things in your sleep you cannot remember, your mood changes, or you feel you cannot sleep without the tablets.

You can report side effects to the MHRA through the Yellow Card scheme.

Frequently asked questions

Zolpidem or zopiclone: which is better?

Neither is better for most people. NICE found a lack of compelling evidence to tell zolpidem and zopiclone apart. Zolpidem leaves the body faster, and the NHS no-driving window is 8 hours compared with 12 hours for zopiclone.

Is eszopiclone available in the UK?

Yes. Eszopiclone is now licensed in the UK as Lunivia, a prescription-only medicine for insomnia in adults. It is closely related to zopiclone and carries a similar 12-hour driving warning.

Is diazepam or zopiclone better for sleep?

Zopiclone is licensed for short-term insomnia. Diazepam is licensed for severe anxiety, including anxiety with insomnia, not for sleep problems on their own. Your prescriber decides which fits your situation.

Is melatonin safer than zopiclone?

They are different medicines with different licences. Circadin is licensed for adults aged 55 or over with primary insomnia, for up to 13 weeks. Melatonin can still cause drowsiness, and it needs a prescription in the UK.

Temazepam vs zopiclone: what is the difference?

Temazepam is a benzodiazepine and zopiclone is a Z-drug. Both are licensed for short-term severe sleep problems and are Class C. Temazepam is in Schedule 3, so stricter legal rules apply.

Can I switch from zopiclone to zolpidem if it stops working?

Not on your own. NICE says switching should only happen for side effects caused by a specific medicine, and someone who has not responded to one should not be given another. Speak to your prescriber.

References

  1. Zaleplon, zolpidem and zopiclone for the short-term management of insomnia (TA77): recommendations, NICE, accessed November 2026
  2. Insomnia, NHS, page last reviewed 19 March 2024, accessed November 2026
  3. Zopiclone, NHS, page last reviewed 22 June 2026, accessed November 2026
  4. Zolpidem, NHS, page last reviewed 22 October 2026, accessed November 2026
  5. Diazepam, NHS, page last reviewed 2 June 2026, accessed November 2026
  6. About melatonin, NHS, page last reviewed 13 February 2023, accessed November 2026
  7. Zopiclone 7.5 mg film-coated tablets: Summary of Product Characteristics, emc, last updated 15 April 2026, accessed November 2026
  8. Zolpidem Tartrate 10 mg Tablets: Summary of Product Characteristics, emc, last updated 26 November 2025, accessed November 2026
  9. Lunivia 2 mg film-coated tablets (eszopiclone): Summary of Product Characteristics, emc, last updated 20 February 2026, accessed November 2026
  10. Lunivia film-coated tablets: Patient Information Leaflet, emc, leaflet revised October 2025, accessed November 2026
  11. Diazepam 5 mg tablets: Summary of Product Characteristics, emc, last updated 16 February 2026, accessed November 2026
  12. Temazepam 10 mg/5 ml oral solution: Summary of Product Characteristics, emc, last updated 10 November 2022, accessed November 2026
  13. Circadin 2 mg prolonged-release tablets: Summary of Product Characteristics, emc, last updated 11 February 2025, accessed November 2026
  14. Slenyto 1 mg prolonged-release tablets: Summary of Product Characteristics, emc, last updated 27 June 2025, accessed November 2026
  15. Misuse of Drugs Act 1971, Schedule 2 Part III: Class C drugs, legislation.gov.uk, accessed November 2026
  16. The Misuse of Drugs Regulations 2001, Schedule 3, legislation.gov.uk, accessed November 2026
  17. The Misuse of Drugs Regulations 2001, Schedule 4, legislation.gov.uk, accessed November 2026

This article is for information only and does not replace advice from your doctor or pharmacist. Read our medical disclaimer.

Questions about your own medicine?

Speak to the doctor or pharmacist who looks after you before you start, change or stop any medicine. If you think you are having a serious reaction, call 999.